Alicia and Regina North are sisters who are as different as night and day. Alicia has one purpose in her life and she vowed she would hold true to it. She would never let herself fall in love again. In her opinion, it was just too risky. One's heart was too fragile to subject it to the uncertainties of love, even though most people considered her only stubborn and prideful. Regina's carefree attitude disturbs her sister as she tries to pick an eligible gentleman for her beau. While Alicia and Regina deal with their feelings, the town of Bridle Creek is dealing with something far worse. Several farms are being intruded upon and the thieving is growing worse as each week passes. Will Bridle Creek be able to pull through the burglaries or will countless people lose their farms? Will Regina realize where her true love lies? Will Alicia overcome her own heart and allow herself to love again or will her fear and stubborn pride be her own undoing?