Butch Walker
has been toiling away somewhere just outside the spotlight of rock & roll for the better part of two decades, eventually carving out a curious niche for himself. Opportunities came and went beginning with
SouthGang
, a metal band in the time of grunge, then running through
the Marvelous 3
, whose 1999 hit "Freak of the Week" showed
Walker
had a commercial ear. He traded upon that skill, working behind the scenes as a collaborative songwriter as he cranked out his own records, establishing enough connections to actually get him placed on the 2008 reality show competition Rock Star: Supernova, all of which didn't do much in terms of getting him another hit of his own.
somewhat retreated from the radio game in 2010 when he formed the Americana-ish band
the Black Widows
, but 2014's
Afraid of Ghosts
takes this direction even further. Leaving behind
but gaining a conspirator in
Ryan Adams
,
essentially designs
as an homage to its producer.
Adams
set up shop in his PAX AM studios and directed
through a sleepy, sepia-toned collection of tastefully rustic ruminations. It sounds more like an old-fashioned
record, one that alternately recalls
Heartbreaker
and
Love Is Hell
, than 2014's unapologetically glossy
and, pro that he is,
's craft is sturdy too; there are strong bones underneath the moody surface, songs that emphasize his skill at construction more than melody. As it somewhat deemphasizes
's way with big hooks -- the very thing that made him an in-demand session man --
isn't as immediate as some of his other records, but it will suit the needs of anybody craving a record that sounds like
used to make them back in the day. ~ Stephen Thomas Erlewine