The first two singles off
After Hours
were released within three days of each other in November 2019. "Heartless," a boastful belter made with
Metro Boomin
,
Illangelo
, and
Dre Moon
, ticked all the boxes to please
Abel Tesfaye
's base. Pills, cars, fame, women, and the hard-fought reward for all the overindulgence -- a ruthless world view to keep the cycle going -- were all in the mix. "Never need a bitch, I'm what a bitch need/Tryin' to find the one that can fix me," contradictory and confused as ever, made the song entirely on brand. Then came the
Max Martin
-produced isolation anthem "Blinding Lights," an instance of
Tesfaye
reanimating mid-'80s Euro-pop like he did with "Wanderlust." These contrasting previews didn't give away the fact that
is, above all else, a breakup album.
fills much of this neatly sequenced, ballad-heavy set with penitence and longing. He sets the tone with an escapist fantasy that turns into a nightmarish relapse, and is tormented for much of the duration by seeking and receiving salvation and ruination from the same relationship. Some of
's most vivid and piercing lines are herein. Mere minutes after dropping the superbly dispirited "I saw you dancing in a crowded room/You look so happy when I'm not with you," he taunts with "You don't love him, you're just f*ckin'," repeating it like he's convincing himself that he's not jealous. You know he's got it bad when he says he "don't even wanna get high no more." In addition to supplying familiar trap-styled prowling backdrops and some other '80s flashbacks,
and his varying team of co-producers refer to some softer points in the U.K. hardcore continuum dating back to the late '90s -- drum'n'bass on "Hardest to Love," 2-step garage and early dubstep on "Too Late" -- modernizing them with finesse.
and
Martin
venture farthest when they meet synthesizer wiz
Daniel Lopatin
in a dead mall, down by the old Tape World, for "Scared to Live," an adult contemporary number that alludes to '70s
Elton John
but has more in common with '80s love themes by
Phil Collins
Lionel Richie
. It's so clean and down the middle that it resembles a box-office crossover bid from an artiste swallowing his pride to record a tame song he didn't write. It happens to be one of
's best performances, his voice soaring and swooping, signifying numbness and codependency, sorrowful about wasted time while encouraging emotional convalescence. It fits into the album and is a
Weeknd
song as much as the one in which
rap-sings of self-harm and addiction, providing financial support for family and friends, and giving his woman "Philip K. dick." ~ Andy Kellman