Duke Ellington
originally wrote the 50-minute
Black, Brown and Beige
in 1943 for a Carnegie Hall concert, where critics dismissed it as overreaching for a jazz composer. Over the next 15 years, he periodically resurrected it for performances of excerpts or, as in the case of his 1958
Columbia
album, transmuting it into what was essentially a new work.
's
was one of the most extraordinary products of
Ellington
's second stay with the label, growing out of his 1956 Newport triumph, and it was received somewhat more readily than the original 1943 "Black, Brown and Beige." The main problem for those who knew the piece and its history lay in the absence of
Johnny Hodges
, who was hardly ever with the
band during 1958, and on whose talents "Come Sunday," the centerpiece of the original work and even more the core of the revamped
, was built. Instead,
Mahalia Jackson
sings a version of "Come Sunday" that is, if anything, equally affecting, backed by the orchestra led by
Ray Nance
's violin. The result on the original album was a piece that started off in big band-style blues and led to one of
's most moving, wrenching pieces of work, and music that, had it been better known, might also have done more to raise people's consciousness about Civil Rights than 100 folk songs of the period. ~ Bruce Eder