Returning to Carver hasn't been the same since Jesse left, but after almost four years, Riley Regas has gotten used to it. She's picked up the pieces after he broke her heart and has moved on. Evan has shown Riley how to love again, but when she comes home for the summer before her senior year of college, Jesse's unexpected return causes everything she's worked so hard to put behind her to come rushing back. She can't deny she still feels something for Jesse, but how can she forgive the way he left her and what about her future with Evan? With her past and present colliding, what life will she choose and will Riley ever truly find happiness?