Swedish filmmaker
Lasse Hallstroem
's directorial style is marked by a taste for simplicity. He is an old-school storyteller, preferring to step out of the way and let the story speak for itself. The approach has its advantages, but the earnest limpidity of his vision can have a stultifying effect on his films.
Rachel Portman
's innocuously pretty score for
Hallstroem
's innocuously pretty 1999 screen adaptation of
The Cider House Rules
played by the director's rules, melding pleasantly and forgettably into the glossy period landscape. The score brought her an Oscar nomination, but lacked both the eclectic complexity (
Beloved
) and the vibrant playfulness (
Emma
) of her best work. A year later,
's adaptation of the
Joanne Harris
novel
Chocolat
was in many ways as charming and as vapid as
Cider House
. But
Portman
's score was a different story altogether. Throughout
,
's rich and airy melodies float sweetly across the screen, mischievously hinting at hidden meanings and darker themes. The music does not so much capture as create the whimsical and mysterious atmosphere of the film, blending breezy French orchestral allusions with otherworldly Andean flutes and rambling gypsy guitars in an effective sonic representation of the cultural clash between
Juliette Binoche
's South American mystic,
Johnny Depp
's Irish river rat, and the conservative French town that brings them together.
Depp
's fans will undoubtedly be delighted by his impressive fretwork on the
Django Reinhardt
and
Duke Ellington
gypsy guitar pieces that begin and end the soundtrack album. But
's is the film's most impressive performance. She proves to be the perfect composer to help
project the tale's subversive feminine energies. ~ Evan Cater