If
James Brown
is
Soul
Brother Number One, you can make a very credible case for
Dan Penn
being number two. The Alabama native has had a hand in writing a fair number of classic
soul
songs, and here he commits his versions of them to tape for the first time, recording, of course, in Muscle Shoals, with their fabulous house band, and a horn section including former
Memphis Horn
member
Wayne Jackson
. It's a tall order
Penn
sets himself, offering himself up for comparison with greats like
James Carr
,
Aretha Franklin
, and
James and Bobby Purify
, who have sung his songs -- and that's just the start of the list. However, he comes out very well, beginning with a quiet take on
"The Dark End of the Street,"
coming across like a note to a secret lover, rather than a cry of pain.
"It Tears Me Up"
conveys the anguish,
"You Left the Water Running"
bounces in its pain, and
"Do Right Woman Do Right Man"
is advice to a friend, instead of
Aretha
's extra freedom cry for equal rights.
"I'm Your Puppet"
becomes a sigh of resignation. Given tracks like that, the other songs will inevitably suffer by comparison, and, to be fair,
"Memphis Women and Chicken"
is little more than a throwaway. But even the lesser-known material from a craftsman-like
is head and shoulders above most of the competition, and
"Zero Willpower,"
a song that he took 20 years to complete, has
classic written all over it, as good as the greatest hits.
can't just write 'em, he can perform 'em too, in a manner as soulful as the greats, as this record shows. The man deserves to be an American musical icon. ~ Chris Nickson