The Jackson 5
were not the first group of kids to sing soul -- teenagers were having hits with R&B stretching back to
Frankie Lymon
, after all -- nor were they the only band of their kind in the late '60s. Most major metropolitan centers across the United States had a few groups that were like Gary, IN's
Jacksons
and some even had a hit or two, such as
the Five Stairsteps
, but most of them never made it out of their hometown and were forgotten to everyone outside of hardcore collectors.
Numero
's 2007 compilation
Home Schooled: The ABC's of Kid Soul
rectifies that situation by rounding up 17 of these obscurities from the late '60s and early '70s, all offering proof that
the Jackson 5
were an anomaly in no way other way than their sheer talent. There's plenty that's likeable among these 17 songs -- anybody with a fondness for classic soul is bound to enjoy the basic sound and feel of these sides, and it's hard to not be won over by the open-hearted enthusiasm of the kids, who always seem happy to be making music, never possessing any of the crass careerism that characterized kiddie bands after
Maurice Starr
. So the basic sound of
Home Schooled
is appealing, but the songs are less so, never quite managing to rise above the generic. Where
the Jacksons
were blessed with the good fortune to be brought into
Motown
's hit machine, where there were songwriters sharp enough to write around the group's youth without ever directly addressing it, much of what
has chosen to showcase on
are songs about being young or in school, songs that aren't so much juvenile as they are cluelessly calculating and bereft of a hook, either melodic, rhythmic, or lyrical. They may not be lost gems -- and the rhythms are too wobbly for sampling -- but they are remarkable cultural artifacts, a portrait of a lost era, and that may be enough for some hardcore soul and pop collectors. ~ Stephen Thomas Erlewine