Cindy was hoping that the only drama this Halloween season would be trying to figure out costumes for she and Jeremiah to wear to Geanie and Joseph's costume party. As it turns out, though, there are a lot more tricks in store than treats. When bodies begin turning up with strange, ritual markings on them it puts everyone in town on edge. Suddenly there's a lot more to worry about than the youth group's haunted house event. More than ever Cindy, Jeremiah, and Mark must rely on each other to survive. Lives will be lost and families destroyed before they can put an end to a dark coven's reign of terror.