John Coltrane
appeared at the
Newport Jazz Festival
on five different occasions, the first in 1958 as a member of
Miles Davis
'
Kind of Blue
-era sextet. As a bandleader,
Coltrane
performed at the festival in 1961, 1963, 1965 and 1966, and it is the middle two sets that are combined here on this intriguing release. The 1963 band was a variation on
's classic quartet (
on tenor sax,
McCoy Tyner
on piano,
Elvin Jones
on drums and
Jimmy Garrison
on bass) with veteran drummer
Roy Haynes
sitting in for
Jones
, who was unable to be in attendance.
was back in the drum chair for the 1965 appearance, while
's final
Newport
showing in 1966 found him working with an entirely different band that included his wife
Alice Coltrane
and
Pharoah Sanders
. Since
did lengthy versions of his signature arrangement of
"My Favorite Things"
in both 1963 and 1965 (he did it in 1966, as well), it's impossible not to compare the approach of the two different drummers.
Haynes
has a lighter, skittering touch that gives the piece a kind of airiness while
is all power and propulsion which makes for a more ambiguous and ominous feel. Both versions are striking, but the real treat here is the 23 minute and change take on
"Impressions"
from 1963, which has never before been released in its entirety (an edited version was released in 1978). Here
trade phrases and percussive glides after
Tyner
Garrison
lay out what is a truly wonderful dialogue between two veteran
jazz
musicians. There's little doubt that the quartet hits with more raw power with
driving it, but here
' contribution is perfect for the moment. Taken together, the 1963 and 1965 sets make a nice whole, and having two great drummers with slightly different approaches only underscores how complete
's vision was at this point in his career. ~ Steve Leggett