Tribute collections -- especially those dedicated to a deceased artist by a various group of performers -- are usually a mixed bag by their very nature. A dedicated various-artists set of songs by the towering songwriter
Townes Van Zandt
is even more daunting in concept. That said,
Poet: A Tribute to Townes Van Zandt
, originally issued in 2001, is the exception to the rule in every case. Containing 16 cuts by a stellar cast that includes everyone from
Willie Nelson
and
Nanci Griffith
to
Lucinda Williams
John Prine
with lots of folks in between. Other performers include two songwriters who have done their own full-length tributes to
Van Zandt
's genius:
Jonell Mosser
(whose wonderful
Around Townes
was the very first, issued in the '90s) and
Steve Earle
(whose own 2009 album,
Townes
, is classic in the genre).
Nelson
appears opens the album with an utterly believable reading of the harrowing
"Marie."
Guy Clark
's tender and moving
"To Live Is to Fly"
is performed with the requisite wisdom and eagle eye vision he gives his own songs. It is especially poignant given how close he and
were.
Emmylou Harris
' take on
"Snake Song"
is a spare, darkly spiritual reading.
'
"Nothin,'"
is dredged in her own roots as a blues singer. There are some excellent surprises here as well, such as
"My Proud Mountains,"
performed by
John T. Van Zandt
, the late songwriter's son. The echoes of his father's voice -- whether he likes it or not -- are threaded inseparably with his own in his performance.
Billy Joe Shaver
's reading of
"White Freightliner Blues"
is as hardcore country as the songwriter ever intended. The biggest shock is
Asleep at the Wheel
's
Ray Benson
's cover of
"If I Needed You,"
which is delivered with the emotion of a wise and seasoned old soul. The violins and hand percussion added a gorgeous touch to the song.
Griffith
's version of
"Tower Song"
is arranged in such a way as to accent
's status as a poet; its tenderness and empathy on full display in the grain of her voice.
The Flatlanders
reunite for a hardcore Texas take on
"Blue Wind Blue"
-- all of them in fine voice. And
's skeletal performance of
"Loretta,"
like
Clark
, makes the song sound like his own. .
Mosser
"A Song For"
is a very different kind of interpretation, but like
Earle
's rocking
"Two Girls,"
offers proof of the breadth and depth of
's artistry as a true American folk songwriter that another performer can take a song and add something of her or his own and extend its meaning.
Delbert McClinton
may seem an odd choice for
"Pancho and Lefty,"
but he drenches it with a grainy, leathery expressiveness that is pure Texas, and pure
McClinton
, with traces of blues and R&B injected into the folk and country of the original. Ultimately,
Poet
is an extremely fitting tribute to a legend, and in its performances underscores not only
's reputation among his a peers, but also the enduring relevance and beauty of the work he left behind. [The CD was reissued in 2009.] ~ Thom Jurek