The members of the band Our Lady of Righteous Rage finally know who is behind all of their negative press, and unfortunately, it's someone they all know: David Sarconi. He's Nick's cousin, and Amy's ex. Still, the band decides to carry on, and continue making music, but David seems to be out to destroy their fame. Nick finds himself unable to write new music, and Aidan is still dealing with trouble between himself and his father. The band begins to succumb to their vices, and slowly falls apart. If they're ever going to make music together again, they will have to deal with their personal problems once and for all, and focus on what brought them together in the first place: music.