A young soldier, Peter, returns home and meets an Amish girl, Lovina, along the way. Lovina is pregnant and fearful of returning home to her Amish family where her judgmental father may want to shun her because she is now pregnant out of wedlock. The chivalrous Peter offers to pretend to be her husband in order for her to get things situated at home but the more time they spend together, the deeper they fall in love. However, Peter has a girl back home and begins to feel pulled in both directions. What will the young couple do?