A year -- nearly to the day -- after
Epic
released the single-disc
Number Ones
compilation in November 2003, the long-awaited
Michael Jackson
box set finally saw the light of day. Entitled
The Ultimate Collection
, the 57-track set spans five discs -- four CDs and one DVD containing a live show in Bucharest shot on the
Dangerous
tour -- and runs his entire career, from
the Jackson 5
's early hits for
Motown
to
Invincible
in 2001. It's the first set to cover so much ground, which is eye opening. To hear
Jackson
evolve from the exuberant kid singing
"I Want You Back"
and
"ABC"
to the young adult behind the vibrant
disco
of
"Shake Your Body (Down to the Ground)"
"Don't Stop 'Til You Get Enough"
is exciting and instructive; even if you're familiar with this material, it's different to hear the music change over the course of one disc. Unfortunately,
doesn't contain too many more revelations (although the early, radically different version of
"P.Y.T. (Pretty Young Thing)"
is not only revelatory -- it's practically a different song -- it's also musically noteworthy). Since
has had such a long career filled with so many hits, there are too many hits to fit into the four discs, and not all of them are nearly as invigorating or ageless as much of the music that comprises the first two CDs. These are the discs that are devoted to
,
the Jacksons
, and
Michael
's solo career through
Thriller
, and with only a few exceptions -- such as the ludicrous
"Thriller"
itself -- the music still sounds terrific. The set starts to downshift on the third disc, when
's career started to wind into second gear, at least creatively. This covers
Bad
, a spotty but still effective gloss on
that had several good singles, along with
, a similarly uneven record. Which leaves the fourth disc to chronicle
's muddled '90s and 2000s, selecting hits and album tracks from the commercial disappointments
HIStory
-- the album of original songs included on that two-CD set, not the hits collection -- and
. Throughout the four discs, there are a bunch of rarities scattered about, ranging from demos (including the original
"We Are the World"
featuring only
's vocals) and remixes to unreleased songs, selections from
The Wiz
' duet with
Mick Jagger
on
"State of Shock,"
"Someone in the Dark"
from the hard-to-find
ET's Storybook
, the ridiculously stilted
Captain EO
theme
"We Are Here to Change the World"
(its production seems better suited for
The Adventures of Buckaroo Banzai
than a
Disney
sci-fi flick), and
"Someone Put Your Hand Out,"
an exclusive Pepsi-supported cassingle from the
tour. Some of this stuff is quite good --
"Sunset Driver"
from 1982 and
"Cheater"
from 1987 are so funky, loose, and alive that it's hard not to wish that
didn't fuss over his albums and just record like this all the time -- but a lot of this illustrates
's taste for MOR schlock (such as the children's tale
"Scared of the Moon,"
a tie-in with his 1984 book of the same name). Since that schlock starts to surface halfway through disc two, it bogs down the set -- not enough to completely hurt it, but enough to make this pretty much the province of the hardcore fans, who will delight in the number and variety of rarities here (which is the primary attraction of the set, since the DVD is merely OK and the book is skimpy, offering only a
Nelson George
essay and a time line, along with many photos, most of which look fairly familiar). For the less dedicated, this is just a shade short of being definitive. It may be easy to carp about what's missing on any box set, but fans looking either for a concentrated dose of
at his best -- which would have been
up through and including parts of
-- or a collection of all of his hits will find this somewhat unsatisfactory (for the record, the following hits are all absent on this set:
"The Love You Save,"
"Never Can Say Goodbye,"
"Rockin' Robin,"
"Human Nature,"
"Say Say Say,"
"Another Part of Me,"
"Leave Me Alone,"
"In the Closet,"
"Will You Be There,"
"Scream,"
"This Time Around,"
"They Don't Care About Us,"
"Heaven Can Wait,"
"One More Chance"
). Despite these problems,
comes close enough to getting it right to qualify as a successful box set. ~ Stephen Thomas Erlewine