In the fall of 1882, two bounty hunters track down Christian Gentry in the northern part of the New Mexico Territory and return him to the town of Paradise to stand trial for murder. When his brothers Justin and Charles Gentry hear of his arrest, they embark on a desperate race against time to save Christian from the hangman's noose and quickly discover their brother's fate is in the hands of a crooked town marshal and a double crossing cattle baron, who the locals call El Gato. While Charles and Justin try to clear Christian's name, they discover things aren't as they appear and things turn ugly when they encounter a vile bandit known as the "Butcher".