Trudy Allen is on her way back to the last place on earth she wants to go, to see the last person on earth she cares to see. Yet, there seems to be a will stronger than her own, wooing her back to the place of vicious lies, broken promises and shattered dreams. Twenty years ago, she and Luke McGallagher sat on a concrete bench at Lake Geneva, planning a future while Nat King Cole's Unforgettable blared on the juke box in the nearby dance pavilion. For the past eighteen years, she's struggled to forget. But forgiving? Not a chance in a lifetime.