Martha's Vineyard is a beautiful place for a wedding! Charles Williams is back on the island and this time with a more permanent stay in mind! Charles and Police Chief Laurie Knickles are getting married! Their friends have congregated for the festivities, some Laurie met during The JAWSfest Murders and some she is meeting for the first time. Everyone is on their best behaviour, hoping to make a good impression. But when a near fatal car accident in the middle of the night introduces a stranger to the group, things change, and people start to die. Only days before the wedding, someone is drawing a line through the names on the wedding list and Charles' name is at the top of that list!